Highest Rated FirstLowest Rated FirstNewest Listing FirstOldest Listing FirstSort by TitleSort by AuthorMost Ratings FirstFewest Ratings FirstLatest Publication FirstEarliest Publication FirstRandom Order

Known Unknowns by Brendan Patrick Hennessy 2016 Tags matched: supernatural (60 ratings)

Wayhaven Chronicles: Book One by Mishka Jenkins 2018 Tags matched: supernatural (22 ratings)

Wayhaven Chronicles: Book Two by Mishka Jenkins 2020 Tags matched: Supernatural (18 ratings)

Superstition S2 by 13Leagues 2020 Tags matched: Supernatural (11 ratings)

The Good Ghost by Sarah Willson, Kirk Damato 2022 Tags matched: supernatural (16 ratings)

Disco Elysium - The Final Cut by ZA/UM 2019 Tags matched: Supernatural (9 ratings)

Superstition S1 by 13Leagues 2019 Tags matched: supernatural (13 ratings)

What Fuwa Bansaku Found by Chandler Groover 2016 Tags matched: supernatural (29 ratings)

Vain Empires by Thomas Mack and Xavid 2020 Tags matched: supernatural (24 ratings)

Afflicted

, by Doug Egan (2008)
Tags matched: supernatural
(51 ratings)

The Fog Knows Your Name by Clio Yun-su Davis 2019 Tags matched: supernatural (9 ratings)

Doppeljobs by Lei 2020 Tags matched: supernatural (22 ratings)

Going Down by Hanon Ondricek 2017 Tags matched: supernatural (10 ratings)

Psy High by Rebecca Slitt 2014 Tags matched: supernatural (15 ratings)

Each-uisge by Jac Colvin 2019 Tags matched: supernatural (12 ratings)

A Thousand Thousand Slimy Things by Charm Cochran 2022 Tags matched: supernatural (7 ratings)

Biscuits and Ghosts by Mad Hatter’s Daughter 2020 Tags matched: supernatural (4 ratings)

The Horror of Rylvania

, by D. A. Leary (1993)
Tags matched: supernatural
(8 ratings)

shadows on the mirror by Chrysoula Tzavelas 2003 Tags matched: supernatural (26 ratings)

Sweetpea by Sophia de Augustine 2022 Tags matched: supernatural (14 ratings)

Wayhaven Chronicles: Book Three by Mishka Jenkins 2023 Tags matched: Supernatural (7 ratings)

Blood Moon by Barbara Truelove 2023 Tags matched: Supernatural (5 ratings)

Keeper of the Sun and Moon by Brynn Chernosky 2019 Tags matched: supernatural (6 ratings)

You're In Deep by Xuelder 2022 Tags matched: supernatural (5 ratings)

Edithe Zilonis by Mad Hatter’s Daughter 2019 Tags matched: supernatural (6 ratings)

The Mist by Raymond Benson and Stephen King 1985 Tags matched: supernatural (6 ratings)

Lifestream by Unimatrix Productions 2016 Tags matched: supernatural (2 ratings)

The Lady's Book of Decency by Sean 2018 Tags matched: supernatural (3 ratings)

Each Glimpse A Mirror by Jack Sanderson Thwaite 2020 Tags matched: Supernatural (2 ratings)

Tallest Trees by Peter Bates 2020 Tags matched: supernatural (2 ratings)

The House at the End of Rosewood Street by Michael Thomét 2013 Tags matched: supernatural (14 ratings)

Demon Mark: A Russian Saga by Lorraine Fryer and Vladimir Barash 2017 Tags matched: supernatural (5 ratings)

The Haunted Help Desk by DSherwood 2022 Tags matched: supernatural (5 ratings)

Psy High 2: High Summer by Rebecca Slitt 2019 Tags matched: supernatural (2 ratings)

Moonrise by Natalie Cannon 2019 Tags matched: supernatural (2 ratings)

Haywire by Peregrine Wade 2018 Tags matched: supernatural (8 ratings)

Cheree: Remembering My Murder by Robert Goodwin 2023 Tags matched: supernatural (2 ratings)

Don't Rock The Boat by Elliot Degrassi 2023 Tags matched: supernatural (1 rating)

Mrs. Wobbles and the Tangerine House

, by Mark Marino (2013)
Tags matched: supernatural
(11 ratings)

A Colour Like No Other by TheNamelessOne 2018 Tags matched: supernatural (1 rating)

Kiss The Ghoul

, by chamomeow (2017)
Tags matched: supernatural
(1 rating)

Cold Iron by Masha Lepire and Eugene Fasano Tags matched: supernatural (1 rating)

"So, About Last Night..." by Elissa Black 2022 Tags matched: supernatural (1 rating)

Dark Paths, Leading Nowhere by Raziel Razmattaz and Virtual Venus 2023 Tags matched: supernatural (1 rating)

Daymare #1: "Ritual"

, by Kitty Horrorshow
Tags matched: supernatural
(1 rating)

Time to Feed by Sharang Biswas 2017 Tags matched: supernatural (1 rating)

This Old Haunted House by Jason Love 2022 Tags matched: supernatural (4 ratings)

HAVEN

, by Brooke Burgess (2018)
Tags matched: supernatural
(2 ratings)

Strangers in the Night

, by Rich Pizor (1999)
Tags matched: supernatural
(2 ratings)

The Disappearance of Karen Ward

, by Cloud Buchholz (2012)
Tags matched: supernatural
(3 ratings)

Dead Man's Grave by Jon Tyktor 2015 Tags matched: supernatural

The Sock Puppet Killer by Jason Cantalini 2019 Tags matched: supernatural

The Narrows by Ash Green 2020 Tags matched: supernatural

Dark As Blood by Masha Lepire and Eugene Fasano Tags matched: supernatural

Birthright by Xiulan 2022 Tags matched: Supernatural

The Spirited: Origins by yuveim 2022 Tags matched: supernatural

Bump In The Night by Tori Smith 2023 Tags matched: supernatural

Sweet Magnolias by Cressida St. Claire Tags matched: supernatural

---