Ratings and Reviews by Fredrik

View this member's profile

Show reviews only | ratings only
View this member's reviews by tag: educational
Showing All | Show by Page


99Y, by Martin Vilcans and Staffan Vilcans
Fredrik's Rating:

Treasures of Barsoom, by Microdeal
Fredrik's Rating:

The Hoppit, by Gareth Pitchford
Fredrik's Rating:

The Bog-Nymphs of Neptune, by Kitty Horrorshow
Fredrik's Rating:

Llangollen Rock City, by Sam Thursfield
Fredrik's Rating:

9:05, by Adam Cadre
Fredrik's Rating:

Words of Power, by Stark Springs
Fredrik's Rating:

Not the Lord of the Rings, by Andy Remic
Fredrik's Rating:

Pick Up The Phone Booth And Die, by Rob Noyes
Fredrik's Rating:

Suveh Nux, by David Fisher
Fredrik's Rating:

Fail-Safe, by Jon Ingold
Fredrik's Rating:

Moon Over Jupiter, by Admiral Jota
Fredrik's Rating:

Infiltration on Io, by Ryan N. Freebern
Fredrik's Rating:

Battle of the Planets, by Gunther Schmidl
Fredrik's Rating:

A scurvy gift for Bosn Chuck, by J. Robinson Wheeler
Fredrik's Rating:

The Hose, by Anonymous
Fredrik's Rating:

Plaque, by Admiral Jota
Fredrik's Rating:

Pantheon, Party On, by Tony Delgado
Fredrik's Rating:

Crimson Detritus, by Dana Crane
Fredrik's Rating:

Red Planet, by Conrad Knopf
Fredrik's Rating:

Dungeons of Thuria, by Brian S. Lingard
Fredrik's Rating:

Carma, by Marnie Parker
Fredrik's Rating:

Zork: A Troll's-Eye View, by Dylan O'Donnell
Fredrik's Rating:

Perilous Magic, by David Fillmore
Fredrik's Rating:

Ugly Chapter, by Sam Kabo Ashwell
Fredrik's Rating:

Zauberschloß, by Dennis Merbach
Fredrik's Rating:

Mario, by Harald Bornfleth and Herbert Grosser
Fredrik's Rating:

Gothmog's Lair, by Sean A. Moore
Fredrik's Rating:

Defenders of Gondor, by Nathan Lindsell
Fredrik's Rating:

The Hobbit, by QuestHobbit
Fredrik's Rating:

Star Wars: Escape from Dagobah, by David Leavitt
Fredrik's Rating:

The Relentless Adventures of Captain Speedo, Episode 42: So Long, and Thanks for All the Books, by Gilles Duchesne
Fredrik's Rating:

Jeenin Tonn-nx, by Anonymous
Fredrik's Rating:

The Death of Two Great Minds, by Alex Watson
Fredrik's Rating:

How Many Roads Must a Man Walk Down?, by Tom Waddington
Fredrik's Rating:

Deadline, or, Being Douglas Adams, by Gunther Schmidl
Fredrik's Rating:

A Night at Milliways, by Graeme Pletscher
Fredrik's Rating:

The Quest for the Holy Grail, by Chris Newcombe
Fredrik's Rating:

Ausflug am Wochenende nach München, by Brett Shelton, David Neville, Brian McInnis

7 of 7 people found the following review helpful:
Language education IF -- Still some way to go, January 13, 2011
by Fredrik (Nässjö, Sweden)
Related reviews: educational

I personally owe a great debt to interactive fiction. Games like Adventureland, Zork I and The Hobbit helped me build the foundation of the English I know today, and indirectly paved the way for my current occupation as an English teacher.

Ausflug am Wochenende nach München is a rare example of a game that is written explicitly for language training. This is a great idea. IF for foreign language learners can be tailored to suit the difficulty level of the target group, it can have beginner-level puzzles, and it can be directed to contain useful and relevant vocabulary and content.

In some respects, Ausflug is a good effort. It begins with a tutorial to get the player started in the world of interactive fiction. It comes with a German-English glossary and a primer as pdf files. The language is fairly advanced (written for university students), and is naturally linguistically excellent. The theme of the game (getting started on a journey) is also a good choice for the genre.

Unfortunately, Ausflug suffers from the same problem that practically every other previous attempt to write IF for language education does. Plainly speaking, it is boring. There are practically no puzzles at all that are necessary for completing the game. The only puzzles (two that I found, and very simple ones) allow you to find some more money. Which is not necessary, since the money you have from the start is quite enough to last you through the game. Mostly, the game is spent walking around and examining and purchasing things.

On top of that, the game is poorly coded. Even though it was made in Inform, it feels like playing an old AGT game. Too much information is built into room descriptions, and some things do not change state, even though the game progresses as if they should.

As much as I wish this was a good game, I cannot recommend it to anyone. I hope in the future that some people will make a joint venture between a game programmer and a language teacher. Then, perhaps, we can at last have a good game for language learners.

Was this review helpful to you?   Yes   No   Remove vote  
More Options

 | View comments (5) - Add comment 

Nightmare Planet, by Mike Grace
Fredrik's Rating:

Book of the Dead, by Mark Davies, Andrew Dean, Lee Hodgson
Fredrik's Rating:

Slottet i Zydor, by Joakim Karlsson
Fredrik's Rating:

Around the World in Eighty Days, by Lloyd Holliday
Fredrik's Rating:

Orientation to Van Pelt Library, by Richard Young
Fredrik's Rating:

Escape from the ELI, by Lowell Riethmuller
Fredrik's Rating:

Weekend Survival, by Lowell Riethmuller
Fredrik's Rating:

The Hobbit, by Serhei Makarov
Fredrik's Rating:

The Crack of Doom, by Philip Mitchell, Norton Truter, John Haward
Fredrik's Rating:

The Hobbit II: Search for Smaug, by Nathan Lindsell
Fredrik's Rating:

The Hobbit: Vol I, by Nathan Lindsell
Fredrik's Rating:

Agent 4-F From Mars, by Michael Arnaud
Fredrik's Rating:

Terrormolinos, by Peter Jones, Trevor Lever, Mike Robinson, James Byrne, and Roger Taylor
Fredrik's Rating:

Runestone, by Alan Davis
Fredrik's Rating:

Subsunk Adventure, by Peter Torrance and Colin Liddle
Fredrik's Rating:

Robin of Sherwood - The Touchstones of Rhiannon, by Mike Woodroffe, Brian Howarth, and Teoman Irmak
Fredrik's Rating:

Star Wars, by Pontus Nylander
Fredrik's Rating:

The Dallas Quest, by James Garon, Louella Lee Caraway, Phyllis Wapner
Fredrik's Rating:

Mars, by Delton T. Horn
Fredrik's Rating:

El Poder de la Kínbreton, by Daniel Cárdenas
Fredrik's Rating:

The Fourth Sarcophagus, by Anonymous
Fredrik's Rating:

The High Mountains, by Paul Braithwaite
Fredrik's Rating:

Zauberland, by Philipp Köhn
Fredrik's Rating:

Quest for the Holy Joystick, by Fergus McNeill, Jason Somerville, and Mad Mac
Fredrik's Rating:

Mars, by Anonymous
Fredrik's Rating:

Frobozz Magic Support, by Nate Cull
Fredrik's Rating:

Lost New York, by Neil deMause
Fredrik's Rating:

The Helm, by Simon Jay
Fredrik's Rating:

The Death Star, by Donald Brown
Fredrik's Rating:

Dog Star Adventure, by Lance Micklus
Fredrik's Rating:

Survival, by E. H. Wilson
Fredrik's Rating:

Valkyrie 17, by Tony Barber
Fredrik's Rating:

The Bridge of Catzad-Dum, by Nate Segerlind
Fredrik's Rating:

Haradwaith, by Sam Ruby
Fredrik's Rating:

Return to Moria, by Sam Ruby
Fredrik's Rating:

Quest of Erebor, by Sam Ruby
Fredrik's Rating:

The Forest of Fear, by Sam Ruby
Fredrik's Rating:

Twin Kingdom Valley, by Trevor Hall and P. M. Skinner
Fredrik's Rating:

Castle of Terror, by Graeme Willis
Fredrik's Rating:

Jigsaw, by Graham Nelson
Fredrik's Rating:

Balances, by Graham Nelson
Fredrik's Rating:

Zork II, by Dave Lebling, Marc Blank
Fredrik's Rating:

Adventure, by William Crowther and Donald Woods
Fredrik's Rating:

The Boggit, by Fergus McNeill and Judith Child
Fredrik's Rating:

Bored of the Rings, by Fergus McNeill
Fredrik's Rating:

Barsoom Adventure #1: The Lost City, by Susan Schnitger
Fredrik's Rating:

Enchanter, by Marc Blank, Dave Lebling
Fredrik's Rating:

Plundered Hearts, by Amy Briggs
Fredrik's Rating:

Shadows of Mordor, by Philip Mitchell, John Haward
Fredrik's Rating:

Lord of the Rings: Game One, by Philip Mitchell, Michael O'Rourke, Paul Kidd, Lyn C
Fredrik's Rating:

The Hobbit: The True Story, by Fredrik Ramsberg and Johan Berntsson
Fredrik's Rating:

Bilbo, by Nils Eng
Fredrik's Rating:

London, by Nils Eng
Fredrik's Rating:

Thror's Ring, by Tom Zuchowski
Fredrik's Rating:

The Sands of Mars, by Ted Swartz
Fredrik's Rating:

The Ring of Doom, by Sam Ruby
Fredrik's Rating:

The Mines of Moria, by Sam Ruby
Fredrik's Rating:

Main Hall & Beginners Cave, by Donald Brown
Fredrik's Rating:

The Iron Prison, by Sam Ruby
Fredrik's Rating:

The Hunt for the Ring, by Sam Ruby
Fredrik's Rating:

Assault on Dolni Keep, by Tom Zuchowski
Fredrik's Rating:

Secret Mission, by Scott Adams
Fredrik's Rating:

Sorcerer, by Steve Meretzky
Fredrik's Rating:

Leather Goddesses of Phobos, by Steve Meretzky
Fredrik's Rating:

The Hitchhiker's Guide to the Galaxy, by Douglas Adams and Steve Meretzky
Fredrik's Rating:

Adventureland, by Scott Adams
Fredrik's Rating:

Zork I, by Marc Blank and Dave Lebling
Fredrik's Rating:

The Hobbit, by Philip Mitchell and Veronika Megler
Fredrik's Rating:


Showing All | Show by Page