Home | Profile - Edit | Your Page | Your Inbox Browse | Search Games   |   Log In

Ratings and Reviews by Stian

View this member's profile

Show reviews only | ratings only
View this member's reviews by tag: IFComp 2019 Spring Thing 2018 Spring Thing 2019
1-10 of 129 | Next | Show All


The Prongleman Job, by Arthur DiBianca
Stian's Rating:

Kerkerkruip, by Victor Gijsbers
Stian's Rating:

A Change in the Weather, by Andrew Plotkin
Stian's Rating:

Randomized Escape, by Yvan Uh
An experiment that almost makes sense, December 27, 2019
by Stian
Related reviews: IFComp 2019
Randomized Escape did mostly not make any sense, as even the descriptions seem randomly generated. Still, it tries to be scary, and that is noticeable: There is some thing, in some fog, and some blood. However, as long as passages such as “This van is very dirty. Maybe I should limit my examination to visual perception. And you did.” and “You cannot see any obvious issue through the fog. There is no time for hesitating.” appear, it’s hard to become immersed in the horror. The introduction recommended drawing a map, but I found that to be difficult and not very useful; many rooms have the same name, and the protagonist might suddenly run only to find themselves in a different (random) room. Still, despite not being a particularly enjoyable game, it’s interesting to see an experiment like this.

Limerick Heist, by Pace Smith
It's a limerick heist!, December 27, 2019
by Stian
Related reviews: IFComp 2019
Limerick Heist does impress,
its story impresses no less.
I thought I was smart
but then must restart,
finding myself in a mess.

Flight of the Code Monkeys, by Mark C. Marino
Neat concept that teaches programming, December 27, 2019
by Stian
Related reviews: IFComp 2019
Flight of the CodeMonkeys is based on the neat idea of setting an IF into a programming notebook. You can play it even if you don’t know any programming from before, and probably even learn something through it. The game doesn’t go very deep into coding, however, and the opportunities you get to hack the system end up feeling less than immersive. Still, I liked the idea, and think it demonstrates how you can use IF as an educational tool to teach programming. My main criticism of this game is that you need to create a Google account in order to play it.

Fat Fair, by AKheon
Impressive implementation, crass humour, December 27, 2019
by Stian
Related reviews: IFComp 2019
Fat Fair is really well implemented, with special verbs, alternative endings and several secrets. The main task is rather simple to achieve, while the challenge lies in finding the alternative paths. I was very impressed to read in the ‘about’ section that this was the author’s first game. However, the humour that is integral to the game did not really appeal to me. I really hope the author continues to make IF games, though somewhat less crass.

Mental Entertainment, by Thomas Hvizdos
Good backstory, disappointing IF, December 27, 2019
by Stian
Related reviews: IFComp 2019
Mental Entertainment was a curious piece of IF. It is essentially puzzleless, and although conversational you don’t really get responses to anything but the set of keywords listed in ‘about’ and whatever the replies are to those. You are assigned the heavy task of assessing three people’s mental states and deciding whether they are addicts or not. However, the outcome is the same regardless of your decision; you do not get to see the consequences.

As such, as a work of IF, Mental Entertainment doesn’t really reach very far. What we are left with then is the fabula, the story behind the plot. In this, Mental Entertainment is slightly unique and somewhat cliché; we are exposed to a world of the future where everything right and real is gone, and where VR is the only reasonable escape. To me, this is a decent premise, and the world has been crafted with passion and care, but the IF aspects, or rather lack thereof, left me somewhat dissatisfied.

Gone Out For Gruyere, by B F Lindsay

1 of 1 people found the following review helpful:
Cheese and humour, December 27, 2019
by Stian
Related reviews: IFComp 2019
Gone Out for Gruyère is based on one of the most silly, crazy and absurd premises I have encountered in an IF. It’s also quite easy; here I ultimately find the writing and the humour more essential than the puzzles. And with a talking cheese that mocks your every move as its antagonist, it is very funny.

Frenemies; or, I Won An Andy Phillips Game!, by B F Lindsay

1 of 1 people found the following review helpful:
Impressive homage to Andy Phillips, December 27, 2019
by Stian
Related reviews: IFComp 2019
The homage that is Frenemies does not only feature a die-hard fan who has filled his dorm room with objects from Andy Phillips’ games, but is also centered around a single puzzle that should make Phillips proud. Of the games alluded to in Frenemies, I have only played Inside Woman 1, which is without doubt the longest and most difficult game I have completed. The main puzzle in Frenemies is possible to solve in five minutes, but more likely to take you close to two hours of tears and frustration, followed by a deep and fulfilling sense of accomplishment. If the game were significantly larger, I would have probably regarded this puzzle as too clever, but as it stands more or less alone in a one-room game, I think it’s just perfect. The writing is mostly excellent, though the humour a bit juvenile at times, while the protagonist carries some of the naïve, self-mocking touch that characterised Tom from the Bullhockey games.


1-10 of 129 | Next | Show All